10 USED TOYOTAS THAT HAVE TANK-LIKE RELIABILITY

Alongside good fuel economy, cheap repair bills, and comfort, buying a used vehicle in 2024 can be a challenge to get everything you want, but one of the most important things for many of us is how well our new used car can withstand the demands of being used daily. With automakers such as Honda, Acura, Kia, Mazda, and Lexus all scoring highly for reliability, there are lots to choose from, depending on your budget. But, as we all know, Toyota is famously rugged and dependable and offers a huge number of used vehicles that are built to last.

With Toyota's dedication to using high-quality materials, stringent quality control, lean engineering methods, and Toyota's Takumi Masters, who have spent thousands of hours honing their crafts, it is no wonder that used Toyota vehicles offer reliable rides. From tough Toyota pickup trucks and SUVs to their hatchbacks and sedans, there are plenty of used Toyota vehicles that are known to just keep going.

This is why we have decided to look into 10 Toyota models that have tank-like reliability. We have used multiple sources to bring you information about these top 10 reliable used Toyota vehicles and have included information about their running costs, how much you can buy one for today, the pros and cons of each model, their performance specifications, and what makes them ideal used vehicles.

2013 Toyota Sienna

Reliability rating: 80/100

Minivans are seldom seen on the new car market with the rise of the SUV and crossover segments, so with a reliability rating of 80 out of 100, available seating for up to 8 people, and available from between approximately $9,600 to $14,800, the 2013 Toyota Sienna could be seen as a savvy buy if you are looking to haul the family around in a minivan with a proven track record for less than the average cost of a new vehicle in 2024.

Performance Specifications

Available in 5 trims, the Toyota Sienna boasts a maximum cargo capacity of 150 cubic feet, features ample front legroom of 40.5 inches, and showcases safety features such as stability control, traction control, ventilated brake disks, four-wheel ABS, and emergency braking assist, so safety and convenience are at the forefront of its design.

• Toyota Sienna L. Standard 7-passenger seating with second-row captain's chairs.
• Toyota Sienna LE. Available in 7 or 8-passenger configurations; the 8-passenger model adds a removable second-row center seat.
• Toyota Sienna SE. Seats 7 passengers, featuring sportier design elements with second-row captain's chairs.
• Toyota Sienna XLE. Available in 7 or 8-passenger configurations; leather-trimmed seating and reclining second-row seats for added comfort.
• Toyota Sienna Limited. Standard 7-passenger seating with luxury features, including premium leather captain's chairs and power third-row seats.

All 2013 Sienna models come equipped with the 3.5-liter V-6, and if you feel like towing, the Sienna is also capable of towing a respectable amount while keeping you comfortable in the plush seats.

Pros

• All-wheel drive is available.
• Powerful V-6 under the hood.
• Lots of available seating.

Cons

• Technology is dated compared to newer models.
• Owner reviews have complained about barge-like handling.
• Interior styling is not to everyone's taste.

2019 Toyota Highlander

Reliability Rating: 80/100

Though there is no information on Repair Pal for the 2019 Toyota Highlander, they have said that the average annual maintenance cost for a Highlander is $489, which puts it below the average yearly maintenance cost of $521 for compact/crossover SUVs. There are 5 trims available for the Highlander, the LE, LE Plus, XLE, SE, and the Limited, and it currently has a used price range of $21,700 and $36,052.

Performance Specifications

Though slightly lower compared to the Toyota SUV with the highest driving range in 2024 , the 2019 Highlander is still capable of achieving a reasonable combined MPG rating of 23 MPG, a driving range of up to 442 miles, and costing you on average $2,050 a year on gas. The Highlander Hybrid though, is capable of a more impressive combined MPG rating of 28 MPG, costing you $1,700 a year on gas, and is capable of driving 482 miles on a single tank. Along with the stellar reliability record, the 2019 Highlander is also relatively cheap to fuel.

Pros

• Three engine options are available, including a more frugal hybrid.
• Good safety features; Toyota Safety Sense that includes adaptive cruise control, lane departure warning, and automatic emergency braking.
• Reviews have complemented the quiet interior.

Cons

• Though relatively new, the interior is dated.
• Doesn't feature Apple CarPlay or Android Auto.
• The base trim (Highlander LE) lacks fewer standard features compared to rivals and requires upgrades to higher trims for features such as navigation or a power liftgate.

2016 Toyota Prius

Reliability Rating: 83/100

Renowned for its extremely high fuel efficiency, the Toyota Prius is a car that helped to shape the hybrid segment and has become infamous for cheap running costs and tank-like reliability thanks to the utilization of the Toyota Hybrid Synergy Drive hybrid system, which was showcased in the 1997 Prius and has been continually improved over the decades, and its dependable Atkinson-cycle engine, which is designed for efficiency and reduced wear, hence the lower output.

The 2016 Prius, as part of the 4th generation, is no exception and has been scored highly by both owners, who rated it alongside J.D. Power, and Repair Pal, who have given it a reliability score of 4 out of 5, placing it 10th out of 25 mid-sized cars.

Performance Specifications

There are 6 available trims for the 2016 Toyota Prius, including the Two, Two Eco, Three, Three Touring, Four, and Four Touring. The base trim is equipped with features like a rearview camera, a 6.1-inch touchscreen, and keyless entry. As you move up the trims, more advanced features are added. The Three boasts an upgraded infotainment system with a 7.1-inch touchscreen, integrated navigation, and wireless smartphone charging.

Higher trims like the Four Touring come with advanced features such as SofTex synthetic leather upholstery, heated front seats, and blind-spot monitoring. The Touring trims also feature sportier touches, including larger 17-inch alloys and additional suspension tuning for a firmer ride. One of the key things for those of you looking for a safe used car will like to know is that Toyota Safety Sense, which includes automatic emergency braking, lane departure alert, and adaptive cruise control, is featured across all trims.

Pros

• High fuel economy of up to 52 combined MPG.
• Low fuel costs of $900 a year on gas and the potential to save approximately $4,000 on gas over 5 years compared to other cars.
• Relatively low used price of between $13,720 and $17,810.

Cons

• Some owners have complained about a firm ride, not just on the sportier trims.
• The exterior and interior design is not to everyone's liking.
• Reviews have said that the Prius feels sluggish when accelerating.

2013 Toyota Tacoma

Reliability Rating: 86/100

Like most Tacomas, the 2013 Toyota Tacoma is celebrated not only for its high-reliability rating but also for its exceptional off-road capabilities, making it one of the best off-road trucks of all time . But with such an accolade, there has to be a reason, and the Tacoma has a whole host of them.

Boasting available locking rear differential, upgradeable Bilstein shocks, a sold frame build, high ground clearance of 9.3-inches, multi-terrain select, and durable skid plates that protect the fuel tank, underbody, and vital components when you are tearing around the trails, the Tacoma is bred for the dirt and sand.

Performance Specifications

The 2013 Toyota Tacoma is still commanding higher used prices, with the average used price of $26,135, but with the current state of the used vehicle market still favoring used trucks over other used vehicles, and with the Tacoma's solid track record, it is little surprise these hardy trucks still have such a following and are still popular among off-roaders and those of us who need to haul and tow for work.

It is worth noting though, that despite the NHTSA giving the 2013 Tacoma a 4 out of 5 stars safety rating, there have been 6 recalls for this model year for reasons which include the accessory hood scoop may detach, incorrect tire placard information, brake actuator assembly may disable, and valve springs may fail, causing your engine to stall. If you are looking to buy a 2013 Toyota Tacoma, it is advisable that you check that all of these points have been addressed.

Pros

• Very capable off-road, especially the TRD Off-Road trim
• Reasonable towing ability from the V-6
• Multiple configurations available (Regular Cab, Access Cab, Double Cab)

Cons

• Poor fuel economy; the Tacoma V-6 can only achieve a combined MPG rating of 18 MPG
• Basic and dated interior
• Compared to rivals, owners have complained about stiff suspension on normal roads

2017 Toyota RAV4

Reliability Rating: 87/100

With a used price range of $16,051 for the base trim (LE Sport Utility), to $20,618 for the highest trim (Platinum Sport Utility), the 2017 Toyota RAV4 boasts a relatively low used price alongside a very high-reliability rating.

Boasting an exterior design that strikes a balance between ruggedness and urban appeal, the Toyota RAV4 doesn't look out of place on the commute to work or towing a limited amount around. Featuring a prominent hexagonal front grille, slim headlights, and sharp angular lines, the 2017 RAV4 boasts an athletic and aerodynamic appearance, while the LED daytime running lights and taillights enhance visibility and add a stylish touch.

Performance Specifications

If you are looking for a more fuel-savvy option, the 2017 RAV4 is also available equipped with a frugal hybrid powertrain that vastly improves its fuel consumption. The NHTSA has also given the 2017 RAV4 a 5-star overall safety rating, while Car Edge has given the RAV4 an 'A+' rating for value and has said that the RAV4 is one of the best vehicles to own in terms of value depreciation over 3, 5, and 7 years.

So, along with the potential for low annual fuel costs of between $1,500 and $1,990, depending on what engine option you choose, and low maintenance costs of $429, the 2017 Toyota RAV4 could make for a savvy used Toyota buy.

Pros

• Good cargo capacity of 73.4 cubic feet.
• A hybrid engine option is available, which can achieve a combined MPG rating of 32 MPG.
• Owners have complimented the smooth and comfortable ride.

Cons

• Low towing capacity compared to rivals.
• Owners have complained about wind speed on the highway.
• ICE version can only muster a combined MPG rating of 24 MPG.

2011 Toyota Camry

Reliability Rating: 87/100

Along with a high J.D. Power reliability score, the 2011 Toyota Camry has received positive reviews from owners who have left a rating of their model on Car Survey.org. One owner gave the Camry an overall score of 8.4 out of 10 and scored it 10 out of 10 for reliability, while they were generally positive about owning a 2011 Camry and also rated the comfort as 10 out of 10, the running costs 8 out of 10, but scored its performance low, with a rating of 4 out of 10.

Performance Specifications

The 2011 Camry features a conservative yet functional design, both inside and out. The exterior presents the Camry as a clean and understated sedan with smooth-flowing lines and a simple front grille. The exterior is available with upgraded 16 or 17-inch wheels, so if you are looking for an extra bit of shine, keep your eyes on the market for what has been added.

Inside, the Camry focuses on comfort and space, with a well-organized dashboard featuring large, easy-to-use controls. The materials are more durable than they are luxury, but the ample passenger room, relatively large trunk space of 15 cubic feet, and low average used price of $8,612 could make up for that.

Pros

• Smooth ride quality.
• Spacious interior, boasting 41.7-inch front legroom and 38.3-inch rear legroom.
• Low maintenance cost of $388 a year.

Cons

• Dated design.
• Base trim engine is lackluster.
• No standard tech features like Bluetooth and the Toyota infotainment system of the time.

2013 Toyota Tundra

Reliability Rating: 88/100

As a powerful, versatile, and dependable pickup truck, the 2013 Toyota Tundra boasts a lot of what we love about a highly-capable Toyota off-roader . Featuring a bold and imposing exterior design, boasting a wide stance, a large front grille, and pronounced wheel arches, it bellows ruggedness and capability.

The interior is utilitarian and spacious, particularly the CewMax model, which provides ample legroom in both rows. Designed with durability in mind, the lower trims are fairly sparse, but the higher trims are available with more luxury touches, such as leather upholstery, heated seats, and a premium sound system.

Performance Specifications

Repair Pal has given the Tundra an average reliability rating of 3 out of 5 and an average yearly maintenance bill of $642, while J.D. Power, from owner surveys, has given it a more respectable score of 88 out of 100 and an overall score of 85 out of 100, placing it second, behind the 2013 Ram Truck 1500, for best large light duty pickup trucks of 2013.

With owners paying between $12,466 and $24,405, depending on what trim you buy, the 2013 Tacoma does a good job of blending durability and work rate with a relatively low used price, but is not for used pickup truck owners who are looking for a fuel-economical life, with poor fuel consumption statistics across the board, regardless of what one of the three powerful V-engines that is equipped in the example you find.

Pros

• Great off-road capability.
• Good amount of cargo space, with 89.7 cubic feet of space.
• Three powerful engine options.

Cons

• Dated design compared to newer models.
• Limited safety features compared to modern pickup trucks.
• Poor fuel economy with a combined MPG rating of 17 MPG when equipped with the 4.0-liter V-6, 16 MPG when equipped with the 4.6-liter V-8, and 15 MPG when equipped with the 5.7-liter V-8.

2017 Toyota 4Runner

Reliability Rating: 88/100

The 2017 Toyota 4Runner is a game-changing mid-sized SUV that boasts everything we love about a rugged off-roading menace and a reliable Toyota. Featuring a rugged and bold exterior design, muscular stance, high ground clearance of 9.6 inches, and large wheel arches, the 4Runner looks every bit as capable as it truly is.

The front fascia is highlighted by a prominent grille with chrome accents and aggressive-looking headlights that contribute to its commanding presence. Adding to its rugged appeal, the 4Runner is available with features like roof rails, skid plates, and 17-inch or 20-inch wheels, enhancing its utility and rugged style.

Performance Specifications

2017 Toyota 4Runner Trims & Average Used Prices

The 2017 4Runner is built for serious off-road adventures, with features designed to tackle challenging terrains, such as its body-on-frame construction and part-time 4WD system make it well-suited for tough environments. The available Crawl Control (CRAWL) and Multi-Terrain Select system allow you to adjust the 4Runner's responses and performance based on the terrain you are driving, while the TRD Pro and TRD Off-Road trims are available with locking rear differentials and off-road tires to enhance your off-road adventure.

Pros

• Great for off-roading.
• High reliability and rugged design.
• Decent towing capacity.

Cons

• Owners have mentioned the firm ride on normal roads.
• Low combined MPG rating of 18 MPG.
• High annual fuel costs of $2,650.

2019 Toyota Corolla

Reliability Rating: 92/100

The 2019 Toyota Corolla is available as a top family sedan or a hatchback that not only boasts a very high reliability score but is also equipped with a range of features that make it a real contender within the used market as a reliable and relatively new car.

Featuring a 6.1-inch touchscreen infotainment system, Bluetooth connectivity, a USB port as standard, and available voice commands, though the Corolla may not be as techy as more modern Toyotas, it is available on the used market from around $16,000 for the base trim and comes equipped with advanced safety features such as lane departure warning, four-wheel ABS, forward-collision warning with automatic emergency braking, and adaptive cruise control on all trims.

Performance Specifications

Showcasing a modern, sleek design with smooth lines, a compact yet stylish profile, and a comfortable interior, the 2019 Toyota Corolla is available in 4 different trims, including the L, LE, SE, and XSE. As you go up the trims, the level of luxury and sportiness varies, with the top trim (Corolla XSE) boasting 18-inch alloys, LED headlights, leather-trimmed seats, a 7-inch touchscreen, sport-tuned suspension, and power-adjustable driver's seat. A 2019 Toyota Corolla XSE will cost you on average $17,219 on the used market.

Fuel Economy.gov says that the most frugal is the 2019 Toyota Corolla Hatchback, featuring the 2.0-liter inline-four and a six-speed manual transmission, and can achieve a combined MPG rating of up to 36 MPG, costing you $1,300 a year on gas.

Pros

• Good rear legroom of 41.4 inches.
• Frugal engine which can achieve up to 36 combined MPG.
• Comes equipped with Toyota Safety Sense as standard.

Cons

• Low trunk capacity of 13 cubic feet compared to rivals.
• Dated interior materials used.
• Owners have mentioned the lack of driving engagement.

2014 Toyota Camry

Reliability Rating: 92/100

The most reliable used Toyota we have sourced is the 2014 Toyota Camry. A reliable, sturdy, and low-value-depreciating family sedan. Available on the used market in 4 trims and boasting a frugal hybrid engine on certain trim levels, despite the Camry's high accolades, it can be bought for as little as $9,222 for the base trim.

• 2014 Toyota Camry L. Features include 16-inch wheels, air conditioning, and a 6.1-inch infotainment touchscreen with Bluetooth connectivity.
• 2014 Toyota Camry LE. Available at an average used price of $10,922. Features include keyless entry, automatic headlights, and a split folding rear seat. The hybrid engine option is available for the LE trim.
• 2014 Toyota Camry SE. A sportier option with 17-inch alloy wheels, sport-tuned suspension, synthetic leather upholstery, and paddle shifters. Available at an average price of $10,590 and available with the frugal hybrid.
• 2014 Toyota Camry XLE. Focuses on a more luxury ride and comes featuring dual-zone automatic climate control, available leather upholstery, heated front seats, and 17-inch alloy wheels. Available on the used market from $10,118.

Performance Specifications

Like a lot of Toyota models, the Camry is rated highly for its low rate of depreciation. According to Car Edge, after 5 years the Camry will only have depreciated in value by 42 percent. After 10 years, it depreciates by only 60.46 percent. That may seem like a lot, but compared to other family sedans like the highly reliable and durable Hyundai Sonata , which has a reliability score of 85 out of 100 and depreciates by up to 68.38 percent, it retains its price at a better rate.

The reasons behind this are simple; the Toyota Camry is a highly sold sedan, so there are a lot of examples of them still on the road, they are extremely reliable, they are designed for comfort, and they have a low annual fuel cost of $1,200 to $1,900, making them an extremely popular choice for those of us looking to buy a good used Toyota all-rounder.

Pros

• Hugely reliable used Toyota.
• Low annual maintenance cost of $387.
• High combined MPG rating of up to 40 MPG, dependent on trim.

Cons

• Bland interior design.
• Limited rear-seat headroom of just 38-inches.
• The design is centered on comfort rather than performance, so the handling is not as precise as some other similarly aged sedans.

2024-09-27T08:02:10Z dg43tfdfdgfd